Benedict Arnold
The General Who Changed Sides
On the morning of September 25, 1780, General Benedict Arnold sat at breakfast. His house was across the river from West Point. He was in charge of that fort. A rider brought him a letter. It said a man had been caught with secret papers. Arnold got up from the table. He rode to the river. His boat crew rowed him to a British warship.
A Fighting General
Arnold was born in Norwich, Connecticut, in 1741. When the war began in 1775, he joined the American side. That May he helped capture Fort Ticonderoga from the British. Then he led a hard march through the woods of Maine to attack Quebec. He was shot in the leg.
In 1777 the British marched south from Canada. The two armies fought at Saratoga, New York. The American general there had taken away Arnold's command. Arnold rode into the battle anyway. He led the attack on the British lines. He was shot in the same leg again. The British army gave up ten days later. After that, France joined the war on the American side.
Feeling Cheated
Arnold felt that Congress had treated him badly. In 1777 Congress had promoted five generals over him. It also asked hard questions about his money. In 1778 he took charge of the city of Philadelphia. He spent a lot of money there. In 1779 he married Peggy Shippen. Her family had friends on the British side.
One month after the wedding, Arnold wrote a secret letter to the British general in New York. He offered to help the British.
The Plot at West Point
In 1780 Arnold took command of West Point. It was a strong fort on the Hudson River. Arnold agreed to hand it to the British. In return he wanted money and a job as a British officer. This was treason. Treason is the crime of turning against your own country.
A British officer named John André met with Arnold. He carried away papers about the fort. On September 23, three American soldiers stopped him on the road. They found the papers in his boot. Two days later Arnold got the news and ran. The Americans hanged André as a spy. A spy is a person who secretly gathers information for the enemy.
A British General
The British made Arnold a general in their army. In 1781 his soldiers burned part of Richmond, Virginia. Then they burned New London, Connecticut. That town was close to the place where he was born. In December 1781 Arnold sailed to England. He died in London on June 14, 1801.
Key facts to use in your script
For your Hook
- Benedict Arnold was one of the best American generals.
- In 1780 he tried to hand a fort to the British.
- Today his name means "traitor."
For your Story
- He helped capture Fort Ticonderoga in 1775.
- He led a hard march to Quebec and was shot in the leg.
- At Saratoga in 1777 he led the attack and was shot in the same leg.
- After Saratoga, France joined the war on the American side.
For your Wrap
- He agreed to give the British a fort called West Point.
- On September 23, 1780, soldiers caught John André with the papers.
- Arnold ran to the British and fought against America.
- He died in London in 1801.
Source Spotlight: A Document from the Time
The moment Washington learns of the treason September 25, 1780; written by Sparks, 1835
Jared Sparks was a historian. In 1835 he wrote a book about Benedict Arnold's life and his treason. He used letters from men who were there. He wrote this 55 years after it happened. This part tells what Washington did on September 25, 1780. That day, papers reached him. Arnold was the trusted leader of West Point. The papers showed he had sold out to the British.
Simplified version, not the source. These are not the writer’s words, so do not quote them. To quote, use the original words below.
Now the mystery was solved. The whole plot was plain to see. There was no doubt about what Arnold had done. It was clear he had gone to the enemy. Hamilton was ordered to get on a horse at once. He was to ride to Verplanck's Point so men could get ready to stop Arnold. […] Washington called Lafayette and Knox. He told them what had happened and showed them the papers. He was perfectly calm. He said only one thing to Lafayette: "Whom can we trust now?"
For a long time, no one else was told the secret. Washington did not show any worry in what he did or on his face. Then dinner was called. He said to the men around him, "Come, Gentlemen; since Mrs. Arnold is unwell, and the General is absent, let us sit down without ceremony." He stayed calm and seemed unworried all through dinner.
Read the original (the real words you can quote)
The mystery was here solved, and the whole extent of the plot was made (plainly visible; obvious). No uncertainty now existed as to the course Arnold had taken. It was clear that he had gone to the enemy. Hamilton was immediately ordered to mount a horse and ride to Verplanck's Point, that preparation might be made for stopping him […] Washington called Lafayette and Knox, to whom he told what had happened, and showed the papers. He was perfectly calm, and only said to Lafayette, "Whom can we trust now?"
For a considerable time no other persons were acquainted with the secret, nor did Washington betray in his actions or (the expression on a face) any symptoms of anxiety or excitement. When dinner was announced, he said to those around him, "Come, Gentlemen; since Mrs. Arnold is unwell, and the General is absent, let us sit down without ceremony." The same (calm control of oneself) and apparent unconcern continued through the dinner.
Make it yours: Two lines of talk carry this whole scene. Retell the moment in your own words. Then pick which line your podcast should quote, and say what your Narrator must explain around it.
Jared Sparks, The Life and Treason of Benedict Arnold (Boston, 1835), ch. XIV · See the source
On the morning of September 25, 1780, General Benedict Arnold sat at breakfast in a house across the Hudson River from West Point. He commanded the fort, and General George Washington was due to arrive that morning. A rider brought Arnold a letter. It said that a man had been caught near Tarrytown with secret papers, and that the papers were on their way to Washington. Arnold left the table, spoke to his wife upstairs, and rode to the river. His boat crew rowed him down to a British warship. Washington arrived about an hour later.
A Fighting General
Arnold was born on January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut. Before the war he was a merchant who traded goods by ship. When the fighting began in 1775, he joined the Patriot side. That May he and Ethan Allen led the men who captured Fort Ticonderoga, a British fort on Lake Champlain. That fall he led a march through the Maine wilderness to attack Quebec, and he was shot in the leg.
In 1777 a British army marched south from Canada. The two sides met at Saratoga, New York. General Horatio Gates, the American commander, had taken Arnold's command away after a quarrel. On October 7, Arnold rode into the battle anyway and led the attack on the British lines. He was wounded again in the same leg. The British surrendered ten days later. The victory helped convince France to join the war on the American side in 1778.
Feeling Cheated
Arnold believed Congress had treated him unfairly. In 1777 Congress had promoted five officers over him, all of them junior to him. Congress also questioned the money he said the army owed him. In June 1778 he became military governor of Philadelphia. He lived well there and spent heavily. In April 1779 he married Peggy Shippen, an 18-year-old whose family had friends on the British side.
About a month after the wedding, Arnold began sending secret letters to General Henry Clinton, the British commander in New York. He offered to help the British for money.
The Plot at West Point
In 1780 Washington gave Arnold command of West Point, the fort that guarded the Hudson River. Arnold agreed to hand it to the British for money and a rank as a British officer. This was treason, the crime of betraying your own country. In September he met Major John André, Clinton's aide, and gave him papers about the fort.
On September 23, 1780, three American militiamen stopped André near Tarrytown and found the papers in his boot. They sent him to an army camp, and the news reached Arnold two days later. André was tried as a spy, a person who secretly gathers information for the enemy. He was hanged on October 2, 1780.
A British General
The British made Arnold a brigadier general in their army. In January 1781 his troops burned part of Richmond, Virginia. In September they burned New London, Connecticut, a few miles from the town where he was born. In December 1781 Arnold sailed to England. He lived for a few years in Canada and then returned to London, where he died on June 14, 1801.
Key facts to use in your script
For your Hook
- Arnold was one of America's best generals early in the war.
- In 1780 he agreed to hand West Point to the British.
- His name has meant "traitor" ever since.
For your Story
- He helped capture Fort Ticonderoga and was shot in the leg attacking Quebec in 1775.
- At Saratoga in 1777 he rode into battle without a command and helped win it.
- Congress promoted five junior officers over him and questioned his money.
- In 1779 he married Peggy Shippen, whose family had Loyalist ties.
For your Wrap
- He agreed to hand West Point to the British for money and a British rank.
- The plot was discovered on September 23, 1780, when John André was caught with the papers.
- Arnold escaped to the British and burned Richmond and New London in 1781.
- He died in London on June 14, 1801.
Source Spotlight: A Document from the Time
The moment Washington learns of the treason September 25, 1780; written by Sparks, 1835
Jared Sparks was a historian. In 1835 he published a book about Benedict Arnold's life and his treason, and he built this scene from letters written by men who were there. He was writing 55 years after the event. This part tells what Washington did on September 25, 1780, when papers reached him showing that Arnold, the trusted commander of West Point, had sold out to the British.
Simplified version, not the source. These are not the writer’s words, so do not quote them. To quote, use the original words below.
Here the mystery was solved, and the whole plot was plain to see. There was no longer any doubt about what Arnold had done. It was clear that he had gone over to the enemy. Hamilton was ordered at once to get on a horse and ride to Verplanck's Point, so that men could get ready to stop Arnold. […] Washington called in Lafayette and Knox, told them what had happened, and showed them the papers. He was perfectly calm, and he said only one thing to Lafayette: "Whom can we trust now?"
For a good while no one else was told the secret. Washington did not show any sign of worry or excitement in what he did or on his face. When dinner was called, he said to the men around him, "Come, Gentlemen; since Mrs. Arnold is unwell, and the General is absent, let us sit down without ceremony." He stayed just as calm and seemed just as unworried all through dinner.
Read the original (the real words you can quote)
The mystery was here solved, and the whole extent of the plot was made (plainly visible; obvious). No uncertainty now existed as to the course Arnold had taken. It was clear that he had gone to the enemy. Hamilton was immediately ordered to mount a horse and ride to Verplanck's Point, that preparation might be made for stopping him […] Washington called Lafayette and Knox, to whom he told what had happened, and showed the papers. He was perfectly calm, and only said to Lafayette, "Whom can we trust now?"
For a considerable time no other persons were acquainted with the secret, nor did Washington betray in his actions or (the expression on a face) any symptoms of anxiety or excitement. When dinner was announced, he said to those around him, "Come, Gentlemen; since Mrs. Arnold is unwell, and the General is absent, let us sit down without ceremony." The same (calm control of oneself) and apparent unconcern continued through the dinner.
Make it yours: Two sentences of dialogue carry this whole scene. Retell the moment in your own words, then decide which line your podcast should quote and what your Narrator must explain around it.
Jared Sparks, The Life and Treason of Benedict Arnold (Boston, 1835), ch. XIV · See the source
On the morning of September 25, 1780, General Benedict Arnold sat at breakfast in a house across the Hudson River from West Point. He commanded the fort, and General George Washington was expected that morning. A rider brought Arnold a letter. It said that a man had been caught near Tarrytown, New York, with papers hidden in his boot, and that the papers had been sent on to Washington. Arnold left the table, went upstairs to speak to his wife, and rode to the river. His boat crew rowed him downriver to a British warship, the Vulture. Washington reached the house about an hour after he left.
A Fighting General
Arnold was born on January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut. Before the war he was a merchant in New Haven who traded goods by ship. When the fighting began in 1775 he joined the Patriot side. That May he and Ethan Allen led the men who captured Fort Ticonderoga, a British fort on Lake Champlain. That fall he led about 1,100 men through the Maine wilderness to attack Quebec, and he was shot in the leg in the assault on December 31, 1775.
In October 1776 Arnold built a small fleet on Lake Champlain and fought a British fleet at Valcour Island. He lost the battle, but the fight delayed the British invasion from Canada until the next year. That invasion ended at Saratoga, New York, in 1777. General Horatio Gates, the American commander there, had removed Arnold from command after a quarrel. On October 7, Arnold rode into the battle without orders and led attacks on the British lines. He was wounded again in the same leg. The British army surrendered on October 17. News of Saratoga helped convince France to join the war as an American ally in February 1778.
Grievances
Arnold believed Congress had treated him unfairly. In February 1777 Congress had promoted five brigadier generals to major general over him, all of them junior to him. Congress also questioned the money he said the army owed him from the Quebec campaign. In June 1778 Washington made him military governor of Philadelphia after the British left the city. He lived well there and ran up debts. On April 8, 1779, he married Peggy Shippen, an 18-year-old from a wealthy family with Loyalist ties. About a month after the wedding, Arnold began writing secret letters to General Henry Clinton, the British commander in New York, offering to help the British for money.
The Plot at West Point
In the summer of 1780 Washington gave Arnold command of West Point, the fort that controlled the Hudson River. Arnold agreed to surrender it to the British in exchange for money and a commission, an official rank, as a British officer. This was treason, the crime of betraying one's own country. In September he met Major John André, Clinton's aide, behind the American lines and gave him papers describing the fort's defenses.
On September 23, 1780, three American militiamen stopped André on the road near Tarrytown. They searched him, found the papers, and sent him to an army post. The officer there sent word to Arnold, which is how the warning reached the breakfast table two days later. André was tried as a spy, a person who secretly gathers information for the enemy, and was hanged at Tappan, New York, on October 2, 1780.
A British General
The British made Arnold a brigadier general. In January 1781 he led a raid up the James River that burned part of Richmond, Virginia. In September 1781 his troops burned New London, Connecticut, a few miles from Norwich, where he was born. In December 1781 Arnold sailed to England. He lived for several years in Saint John, New Brunswick, in Canada, and then settled in London. He died there on June 14, 1801.
Key facts to use in your script
For your Hook
- Born January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut, Arnold was one of the Continental Army's best fighting generals.
- On September 25, 1780, he fled from breakfast to a British warship after learning the plot was discovered.
- His name became an American word for traitor.
For your Story
- He helped capture Ticonderoga in May 1775 and was shot in the leg at Quebec on December 31, 1775.
- At Saratoga, on October 7, 1777, he rode into battle without orders and was wounded in the same leg.
- In 1777 Congress promoted five junior generals over him and questioned his accounts.
- On April 8, 1779, as military governor of Philadelphia, he married Peggy Shippen, from a family with Loyalist ties.
For your Wrap
- He agreed to surrender West Point for money and a British commission.
- The plot collapsed when André was captured on September 23, 1780, and André was hanged as a spy on October 2.
- As a British brigadier general he burned part of Richmond and New London in 1781.
- He sailed to England in December 1781 and died in London on June 14, 1801.
Source Spotlight: A Document from the Time
The moment Washington learns of the treason September 25, 1780; written by Sparks, 1835
Dispatches reach headquarters revealing that Benedict Arnold — trusted commander of West Point — has sold out to the British. The historian Jared Sparks, working from eyewitness letters, reconstructed the scene in 1835. Watch what Washington says — and what he refuses to let anyone see.
The mystery was here solved, and the whole extent of the plot was made (plainly visible; obvious). No uncertainty now existed as to the course Arnold had taken. It was clear that he had gone to the enemy. Hamilton was immediately ordered to mount a horse and ride to Verplanck's Point, that preparation might be made for stopping him […] Washington called Lafayette and Knox, to whom he told what had happened, and showed the papers. He was perfectly calm, and only said to Lafayette, "Whom can we trust now?"
For a considerable time no other persons were acquainted with the secret, nor did Washington betray in his actions or (the expression on a face) any symptoms of anxiety or excitement. When dinner was announced, he said to those around him, "Come, Gentlemen; since Mrs. Arnold is unwell, and the General is absent, let us sit down without ceremony." The same (calm control of oneself) and apparent unconcern continued through the dinner.
Make it yours: Two sentences of dialogue carry this whole scene. Retell the moment in your own words — then decide which line your podcast should quote, and what your Narrator must explain around it.
Jared Sparks, The Life and Treason of Benedict Arnold (Boston, 1835), ch. XIV · See the source
On the morning of September 25, 1780, General Benedict Arnold sat at breakfast in the Robinson house, across the Hudson River from West Point, with two officers from Washington's party. Arnold commanded the fort, and General George Washington was expected at the house that morning. A rider brought Arnold a letter from Lieutenant Colonel John Jameson, the officer commanding an outpost to the south. It said that a man calling himself John Anderson had been caught near Tarrytown, New York, with papers hidden in his boot, and that the papers had been forwarded to Washington. Arnold left the table, went upstairs to speak to his wife, and rode to the river. His boat crew rowed him downriver to the British warship Vulture. Washington reached the house about an hour after he left, and the papers reached him later that day.
A Fighting General
Arnold was born on January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut, the son of a merchant whose business failed. By 1775 he was a merchant in New Haven who owned ships and traded with the West Indies. When the fighting began he joined the Patriot side, and that May he and Ethan Allen led the men who captured Fort Ticonderoga, a British fort on Lake Champlain. That fall he led about 1,100 men through the Maine wilderness to attack Quebec, and he was shot in the leg in the assault on December 31, 1775.
In October 1776 Arnold built a small fleet on Lake Champlain and fought a British fleet at Valcour Island. He lost most of his boats, but the fight delayed the British invasion from Canada until the next year. That invasion, led by General John Burgoyne, ended at Saratoga, New York, in 1777. General Horatio Gates, the American commander there, had removed Arnold from command after a quarrel. On October 7, Arnold rode into the battle without orders and led attacks that broke into the British lines. He was wounded again in the same leg, and the leg never fully healed. Burgoyne surrendered his army on October 17. News of Saratoga helped convince France to sign a treaty of alliance with the United States in February 1778.
Grievances
Arnold believed Congress had treated him unfairly. In February 1777 Congress had promoted five brigadier generals to major general over him, all of them junior to him. Congress also questioned the money he said the army owed him from the Quebec campaign. In June 1778 Washington made him military governor of Philadelphia after the British left the city. He lived well there, ran up debts, and faced charges from Pennsylvania's government over his use of army wagons and supplies. On April 8, 1779, he married Peggy Shippen, the 18-year-old daughter of a wealthy judge whose family had Loyalist ties. About a month after the wedding, Arnold began writing secret letters to General Henry Clinton, the British commander in New York, offering to help the British for money. Clinton's aide, Major John André, handled the correspondence.
The Plot at West Point
In the summer of 1780 Washington gave Arnold command of West Point, the fort that controlled the Hudson River. Arnold agreed to surrender it in exchange for money and a commission, an official rank, as a British officer. This was treason, the crime of betraying one's own country. In September André came up the river on the Vulture and met Arnold behind the American lines. He left with papers describing the fort's defenses, written in Arnold's hand.
On September 23, 1780, three militiamen, John Paulding, David Williams and Isaac Van Wart, stopped André on the road near Tarrytown. He was in civilian clothes. They searched him, found the papers, and refused his offer of a bribe. They sent him to Jameson's post, and Jameson sent word to Arnold, which is how the warning reached the breakfast table two days later. The orders read to the army on September 26 began, "Treason of the blackest dye was yesterday discovered!" André was tried as a spy, a person who secretly gathers information for the enemy. He was hanged at Tappan, New York, on October 2, 1780. Congress gave each of his three captors a silver medal and a pension of $200 a year.
How We Know
Historians know the plot from the papers found on André, from Clinton's secret files, and from the letters Washington and his officers wrote in the days that followed. The famous line in which Washington turns to Lafayette and asks whom they can trust now does not appear in any letter from 1780. It was written down by the historian Jared Sparks in 1835, who drew on what Lafayette remembered decades later. Peggy Arnold's part is still debated. Washington let her return to her family in Philadelphia, and in 1782 King George III granted her a pension of 500 pounds a year for services the British called very meritorious.
A British General
The British made Arnold a brigadier general. In January 1781 he led a raid up the James River that burned part of Richmond, Virginia. In September 1781 his troops burned New London, Connecticut, a few miles from Norwich, where he was born. In December 1781 Arnold sailed to England with his family. He lived from about 1785 to 1791 in Saint John, New Brunswick, in Canada, where he went back into trade, and then settled in London. He died there on June 14, 1801, at the age of 60.
Key facts to use in your script
For your Hook
- On September 25, 1780, Arnold left his breakfast table and was rowed to the British ship Vulture an hour before Washington arrived.
- He was the general who led the attacks at Saratoga and the general who agreed to sell West Point.
- The army's orders of September 26, 1780 began, "Treason of the blackest dye was yesterday discovered!"
For your Story
- His fleet lost at Valcour Island in October 1776 but delayed the British invasion from Canada by a year.
- In February 1777 Congress promoted five brigadier generals over him, and Pennsylvania later charged him with misusing army wagons.
- About a month after his April 1779 wedding, he began secret letters to General Henry Clinton through Major John André.
- Three militiamen stopped André near Tarrytown on September 23, 1780, found the papers in his boot, and refused his bribe.
For your Wrap
- The plot is known from the papers found on André, Clinton's files, and the letters Washington's officers wrote that week.
- Washington's famous line asking Lafayette whom they could trust now appears in no 1780 letter; Jared Sparks wrote it down in 1835 from Lafayette's memory.
- In 1782 King George III granted Peggy Arnold a pension of 500 pounds a year.
- Arnold burned New London, a few miles from his birthplace, sailed to England in December 1781, and died in London on June 14, 1801.
Source Spotlight: A Document from the Time
The moment Washington learns of the treason September 25, 1780; written by Sparks, 1835
Dispatches reach headquarters revealing that Benedict Arnold — trusted commander of West Point — has sold out to the British. The historian Jared Sparks, working from eyewitness letters, reconstructed the scene in 1835. Watch what Washington says — and what he refuses to let anyone see.
The mystery was here solved, and the whole extent of the plot was made (plainly visible; obvious). No uncertainty now existed as to the course Arnold had taken. It was clear that he had gone to the enemy. Hamilton was immediately ordered to mount a horse and ride to Verplanck's Point, that preparation might be made for stopping him […] Washington called Lafayette and Knox, to whom he told what had happened, and showed the papers. He was perfectly calm, and only said to Lafayette, "Whom can we trust now?"
For a considerable time no other persons were acquainted with the secret, nor did Washington betray in his actions or (the expression on a face) any symptoms of anxiety or excitement. When dinner was announced, he said to those around him, "Come, Gentlemen; since Mrs. Arnold is unwell, and the General is absent, let us sit down without ceremony." The same (calm control of oneself) and apparent unconcern continued through the dinner.
Make it yours: Two sentences of dialogue carry this whole scene. Retell the moment in your own words — then decide which line your podcast should quote, and what your Narrator must explain around it.
Jared Sparks, The Life and Treason of Benedict Arnold (Boston, 1835), ch. XIV · See the source